Best Drupal HostingBest Joomla HostingBest Wordpress Hosting
WORLD POLICY ON AIR

World Policy Journal is proud to share our weekly podcast, World Policy On Air, featuring former Newsweek On Air host David Alpern with timely insights from global affairs analyst Michael Moran of Transformative.io, risk and geostrategy consultants. Click here to subscribe on iTunes!

THE LATEST

AddToAny
Share/Save

Is Hazare 's Fight Against Corruption Democratic?

by Rajni Bakshi

In New Delhi, 74-year-old Anna Hazare began a fast on April 5, launching a nationwide anti-corruption movement in the tradition of Gandhi’s satyagraha (soul force) nonviolent resistance. In August for almost two weeks, Hazare went on another hunger strike, creating massive public pressure for the immediate enactment of a Lokpal bill, which would create a powerful independent body (a lokpal) to investigate corrupt officials. As Anna Hazare’s anti-corruption agitation in India continues to gather momentum, many have asked, “How Gandhian is this movement?”

Hazare’s methods may match Gandhi’s, but to really answer the question one needs to look behind the actions associated with the historical Gandhi. The most fundamental creative idea with which Gandhi experimented was self-critical introspection—the faculty for constantly re-examining one’s own motives and methods. Then the opponent need not be encountered or experienced as an offensive “other” but as someone who, just like oneself, has the potential for critical self-reflection and thus can evolve to higher levels of consciousness and action. Hazare’s movement has not met this Gandhian standard yet.

Satyagraha, Gandhi’s philosophy of civil resistance, is fundamentally an inward challenge. Physical non-violence is only its bare minimum component. Its objective is not the ascendancy of any one formula or solution but empowerment of the search for multi-shaded truths. It is this search for truth that is to be made “irresistible”—not the force of a demand backed by large numbers. This endeavor is, above all, an antidote to intolerance. Even if the injustice being resisted is an area of deep darkness, those responsible for it need not be condemned as evil. It is a moral action against the sin, not the sinner.

Hazare’s agitation, however, triggered intolerance towards other approaches of solving the problem of corruption. Those who questioned  Hazare’s solution have been denounced as traitors in banners at protest locations across the country. Some, like Aruna Roy, an architect of the Right to Information law who has been critical of the Hazare draft of the Lokpal Bill, have been bombarded with vicious hate-mail.

The immediate passage of a law creating the institution of a Lokpal may or may not help us wipe out corruption—but intolerance of opposing views will undermine India’s democratic culture. For it depends on open engagement with multiple perspectives and a willingness to be critiqued.

It is dangerous to assume that if big-ticket corruption of elected representatives and government functionaries is tackled, the rest of society will somehow fall in line because the source of the problem is at the top. Rapidly identifying and punishing offenders—at any level of government or in any profession—is  necessary but far from sufficient. Yes, modern parliamentary democracy needs to rely heavily on effective implementation of rule of law. Indeed there is urgent need to press for this and normalize the functioning of institutions in India. But deterrent punishment cannot be the foundation of a society worth living in.

The limitations of deterrent punishment as a means of changing erroneous behavior can be seen in the laws making sex-selection abortions a criminal offence. Enacted almost two decades ago, government policies favoring the girl child are aplenty. But as the census of 2010 showed, the gender ratio is still skewed—940 women for every 1000 men. In the zero to six age group the ratio is much worse—914 girls to every 1000 boys. Clearly the proportion of females in the population is not going to be secured as much through laws as it could be by social renewal. It might be the same with corruption. 

Introspection and a willingness to  take  full responsibility for your immediate domain of action is the core value for a truly democratic culture. This way you seek to change the top by revitalizing the grassroots. You strengthen the struggle against corruption at the top by first bringing change in your own professional and social life. Tolerance and respecting the dignity of all, particularly of those who disagree with us, tends to follow from this commitment to being the change you want to see.

We are not required to ‘follow’ Gandhi—either literally or metaphorically. But his vision of a true democracy depending on a sustained evolution of social energies can be a light on the path ahead. Gandhi himself evolved to the extent of forgiving and embracing murders.

Yes, lives are partly improved by winning on specific demands for laws that compel the powerful to be more accountable. That is vital. But the evolution of democracy may depend on devising ways of converting outrage into well-directed purpose and brashness into a courage that is respectful of different ways of reaching the same goal.

*****
*****

Rajni Bakshi is a Mumbai-based writer. Her most recent book, Bazaars, Conversations and Freedom (Penguin Books India) profiled economists, entrepreneurs, and social activists who challenge free-market orthodoxy.

[Click here to read an extended version at Gateway House]

[Photo courtesy of akshaydavis]

 

 

Share/Save

Anonymous's picture
lokpal bill


too good piece of information, I had come to know about your site from my friend sajid, bangalore,i have read atleast 11 posts of yours by now, and let me tell you, your web-page gives the best and the most interesting information. This is just the kind of information that i had been looking for, i'm already your rss reader now and i would regularly watch out for the new post, once again hats off to you! Thanks a lot once again, Regards, Lokpal bills
Post new comment
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly. If you have a Gravatar account, used to display your avatar.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image. Ignore spaces and be careful about upper and lower case.
FALL FUNDRAISER

 

Around WPI

Jihad in Sub-Saharan Africa 

This paper, “Jihad in Sub-Saharan Africa: Challenging the Narratives of the War on Terror,” examines the history of Islamic movements in Africa's Sahel region to contextualize current conflicts.

World Economic Roundtable with Vicente Fox 

In this World Economic Roundtable, former Mexican President Vicente Fox discusses his current quest to make his country a hub for technology. 

Intern at World Policy


Want to join our team? Looking for an experience at one of the most highly sought-after internships for ambitious students? Application details here.

 

Al Gore presides over Arctic Roundtable 

As the United States prepares to assume chairmanship of the Arctic Council in 2015, this inaugural convening of the Arctic Deeply Roundtables launches a vital conversation for our times. 

SPONSORED

When the Senate Worked for Us:
New book offers untold stories of how activist staffers countered corporate lobbies in the U.S.


Are the U.S. and China on a collision course?
Get the facts from Amitai Etzioni in “Avoiding War with China.”


MA in International Policy and Development
Middlebury Institute (Monterey, CA): Put theory into practice through client-based coursework. Apply by Nov. 30.

WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

To learn about the latest in media, programming, and fellowship, subscribe to the World Policy Weekly Newsletter and read through our archives.

World Policy on Facebook

FOLLOW US